Can a Homeowner Do It Themselves?

Grant rates common plumbing and HVAC projects on a scale of 1 to 10 and explains which ones a handy homeowner can tackle and when to call a professional.

Plenty of home projects are well within reach for a homeowner who is comfortable with tools. Others look simple until something goes wrong. In this video, Grant rates common DIY plumbing and HVAC jobs on a scale of 1 to 10, where 1 is easy and 10 means you should hire a professional.

Quick Ratings

ProjectDifficulty (1 to 10)Grant’s advice
Replacing a leaky faucet3 to 4Doable if you can reach it comfortably
Replacing a toilet4 to 5Doable with care; do not overtighten the bolts
Clearing a slow sink drain1 to 4 (simple), 7 to 8 (chronic)Try a drain tool or hand snake first
Flushing a tank water heater2 to 4Only if it has been flushed regularly
Resetting a garbage disposalEasyKeep the wrench that came with it
Replacing a garbage disposal6 to 7Best left to a plumber
Changing an HVAC air filterEasyEveryone can do it with the right size filter

Replacing a Leaky Faucet: 3 to 4

If you can get under the sink to the faucet, this is a manageable job. It gets hard when the faucet is difficult to reach or fastens to the countertop in an awkward way, and lying on your back reaching up behind the sink is no fun. A homeowner might spend an hour or two. A plumber with the right specialty tools might finish in 15 to 30 minutes.

Replacing a Toilet: 4 to 5

If you know what you are doing, a toilet swap is straightforward. The hardest part is lifting it into place and getting it seated properly. Two tips from Grant:

  • Some plumbers use two wax rings instead of one to make sure the seal underneath is good.
  • If the floor is not perfectly flat, do not overtighten the bolts to stop the rocking. That is a good way to crack a toilet, and the store may not take it back.

Clearing a Slow Sink Drain: 1 to 4, or 7 to 8

A simple, recent clog is usually easy. A thin plastic drain tool with small barbs, about 24 inches long, can reach into the trap and pull out hair and debris. Bathroom clogs are usually hair. Kitchen clogs are usually food.

  • Plungers do not work very well on sinks.
  • A small hand snake can clear many drains.
  • Use chemical drain cleaners sparingly. If you rely on them all the time, there is a bigger problem, and repeated use can eat through pipes.

A chronic or stubborn clog is a 7 or 8, and a plumber may need to bring in larger equipment.

Flushing a Tank Water Heater: 2 to 4

Flushing a standard tank water heater can be fairly easy if you follow the manufacturer’s instructions, have proper isolation valves, and have a floor drain nearby. Grant’s cautions:

  • Inexpensive water heaters often have a plastic drain valve. Open it once and it may not shut again, and then you will be calling a plumber.
  • Do not flush a tank for the first time after it has sat for 8 or 10 years. At that point, the sediment inside is better left alone.
  • If you flush, do it once a year, every year.

Water heater flushing is included in our plumbing Comfort Club when the heater has a proper drain valve, has been flushed regularly, and we can reach it with a drain hose.

Garbage Disposals: Easy to Reset, Harder to Replace

If a disposal stops working, check two things. First, the breaker may have tripped. Second, it may be jammed. Most disposals come with a small wrench that fits into the bottom so you can turn it by hand and free it. An old disposal may simply be locked up for good.

Do not throw that wrench away. If your disposal has no place to store it, tape it to the side of the unit where you can see it.

Replacing a disposal is a 6 or 7. It is not overly difficult, but there are a lot of parts, and the dishwasher connection is where problems show up. Our plumbers often have to correct earlier work that was not done to code or not done properly.

Changing Your HVAC Air Filter: Everyone Can Do It

If your system was installed properly, changing the filter should be easy. Sometimes it slides in behind a small door on the unit, and sometimes you remove a furnace panel to reach it. Grant prefers a separate external filter box, which allows for bigger, better filters with properly marked doors.

Make sure you buy the exact filter your filter cabinet is designed for. A 20 x 24 x 5 filter is not one size fits all. A filter that lets air go around it loses most of its benefit, and one you have to force into place can cause other problems.

  • 1-inch filters: check at least every other month
  • 2-inch filters: about every 3 to 6 months
  • 4- and 5-inch filters: about every 6 to 12 months

Inspect your filter and replace it as needed. You will figure out the right routine for your home.

When to Call Darnold & Lyons

If a project turns out harder than it looked, or you would rather it be done right the first time, our plumbers and technicians serve homeowners throughout Charleston and Central West Virginia.

Call Darnold & Lyons at 304-744-8474 or visit our plumbing services page to schedule service.

Share this post

Related Posts

Secret Link